I received another one of those Hurricane-Katrina-is-divine-judgement-on-US-for-failing-to-look-after-Israel e-mails today (see my previous post on a previous similar e-mail). I didn’t know whether to laugh or weep at the absurdity of some the flawed arguments employed in the message. Some excerpts include :
… pointing out that Ariel Sharon’s then-pending unilateral evacuation of Jewish settlements in the Gaza Strip and northern Samaria was a direct result of intense pressure from American and European leaders, I ended … with this warning: "If it’s true that nations, like individuals, reap what they sow, then folks all over the Western world better get ready for even more difficult days ahead" …
… I first noticed this apparent correlation when the "Perfect Storm" … struck the Atlantic Ocean as the US-promoted International Mideast Peace Conference was taking place in Madrid in late October 1991. At that parlay, George Bush I, whose summer home in Maine was seriously damaged by the raging storm, was joined by European and other world leaders in demanding that intensely-reluctant Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir begin a withdrawal process designed to eventually create a Palestinian state alongside of tiny Israel …
As a result of that conference, direct Israeli-Palestinian peace negotiations were convened under US auspices for the first time ever. They began nearly one year later at the State Department in Washington DC. The date was August 24, 1992-the very day that Hurricane Andrew swept ashore and devastated southern Florida …
Several months later, the controversial Oslo Accord was signed on the White House lawn, sealed by a historic handshake between Yasser Arafat and Yitzhak Rabin, at the benevolent urging of Bill Clinton. Just over one year later, his administration had to deal with the deadliest domestic terrorist attack ever when the Murrah Federal Building was blasted to bits in Oklahoma City …
Bin Laden’s 9/11 Muslim assaults occurred just two days shy of the eighth anniversary of the Oslo Accord White House signing ceremony, held just up the road from the Pentagon. … scholars point out that eight is the biblical number signifying completion of a cycle. Was it a cycle of divine judgment due to America’s relentless promotion of a "peace" plan that would prove deadly and devastating to its small Mideast ally?
As Aaron Klein pointed out exactly two months after the July 7th London bombings, many … believe that Katrina’s wrath was Divine Retribution for America’s pivotal role in the Gaza and northern Samaria forced evacuations, which were completed just two days before the powerful hurricane made landfall between Miami and Fort Lauderdale and five days before it ripped apart much of America’s Gulf coast. Mere coincidence?
And as far as absurdity goes, this paragraph really takes the cake …
It is interesting to note that the name Katrina begins and ends with the vowel "a", as does Gaza. If you take out the middle part, "tri," which means three, you get Kana, which is the name of the Galilee town in Samaria where Jesus did his first public miracle, turning water into wine. If you add a final "n" to that you get Kanan-the original biblical name of the Holy Land.
After reading the message, I couldn’t help but compose a reply to say that I found its reasoning questionable (I was trying to be polite).
While it is not beyond God’s power to bring judgement upon the US and other nations for their "failure" to show greater affection for Israel, I question if the reasoning in the message below is Biblical and sound.
Is the writer simply picking and choosing whatever facts support his theory of divine judgement, while ignoring facts that may contradict his theory ? I observe that there is inconsistency in how "judgement" sometimes takes place on the day that a wrongful act is allegedly carried out (eg. Hurricane Andrew), and at other times a few days later or even as late as one year after the wrongful act (eg. Oklahoma bombings). By this method, you can connect almost any disaster to a wrongful national act, and claim that God is executing some form of dramatic divine judgement.
In this connection, isn’t it just as possible to extrapolate that the terrorist attacks and natural disasters on the US are divine judgement for staunchly supporting Israel ? I believe that is certainly what is on bin Laden’s mind !
Like the writer, I believe that God has created a world that operates according a general rule that people will reap what they sow. However, unlike the writer, I do not think "reaping" always means God going out of His way, intruding into the order of His Creation, to execute judgement in some dramatic way. Rather "reaping" is, most of the time, the natural outcome of a wrong or sinful decision (eg. if I live promicuously, I may get a sexually transmitted disease; if I steal, I may go to jail). So in regard to this matter :
1. Is the devastation caused by Katrina and the other hurricanes a dramatic form of divine judgement, or the US simply reaping what it has sowed as a poor steward of the environment which God has entrusted to it ?
2. Is the tragedy and chaos in the wake of the natural disasters another case of dramatic divine judgement, or the US simply reaping what it has sowed in its failure to implement and execute sound civil emergency plans, and in its neglect of the largely African-American / Hispanic minorities in New Orleans ?
3. Are the terrorist attacks on the US and UK yet another case of divine judgment executed in a dramatic fashion, or a case of richer, developed nations reaping what they have sowed in their oppression of lesser developed nations, whether through colonialism or support of the subsequent corrupt, wicked governments or otherwise, creating a generation of youths who have little hope for the future, but great hatred for the powers that they see as the oppressors responsible for their current plight ?